33 Comments in moderation

West African Court of Appeal & Privy Council

REX

AND

OBASSI ENYI UBI AND OBONWA

WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL HOLDEN AT LAGOS, NIGERIA

23RD DAY OF AUGUST, 1937

2PLR/1937/49 (WACA)

OTHER CITATION(S)

2PLR/1937/49 (WACA)

(1937) III WACA P. 194

LEX (1937) – III WACA P. 194

BEFORE THEIR LORDSHIP:

BUTLER LLOYD, Ag. C.J., NIGERIA

BAKER, J.

BROOKE, J.

BETWEEN:

REX — Respondent

AND

OBASSI ENYI UBI & OBONWA — Appellants

ISSUE(S) FROM THE CAUSE(S) OF ACTION

CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE – SLAVE DEALING:- Conviction for slave dealing contrary to section 369(2) of the Criminal Code – Sex of child subject of charge wrongly stated in information

ORIGINATING COURT(S)

Appeal from Conviction by High Court.

REPRESENTATION:

Ivor Brace for Crown

Appellants in person

DECISION(S) OF THE WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL

Held (Sentence quashed on one count):

1.     That failure to state correctly the sex of child alleged to be subject of slavery was fatal, and conviction on that count quashed.

2.     Appeal as to the second count dismissed.

MAIN JUDGMENT

The following joint judgment was delivered: per BUTLER LLOYD, Ag. C.J., NIGERIA, BAKER AND BROOKE, JJ.

There is nothing in this appeal except for the point raised by the Court that the sex of the child Obassi is wrongly stated in the second count of the information. In our opinion this is fatal, the convictions and sentences on this count must be quashed.

The appeal as to the first count is dismissed.