33 Comments in moderation

West African Court of Appeal & Privy Council

JOSEPH SHEKONI, ELEWU OF EWU, ETC.

V.

CHIEF OGUNYEMI OJOKO

WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL, HOLDEN AT LAGOS, NIGERIA

11TH DAY OF MAY, 1954

W.A.C.A. NO. 3901

2PLR/1954/89 (WACA)

OTHER CITATION(S)

2PLR/1954/89 (WACA)

(1954) XIV WACA P. 504

LEX (1954) – XIV WACA 504

BEFORE THEIR LORDSHIPS:

FOSTER-SUTTON, P.

COUSSEY, J.A.

ABBOTT, J.

BETWEEN

JOSEPH SHEKONI, ELEWU OF EWU, ETC. – Appellant

AND

CHIEF OGUNYEMI OJOKO, SUBSTITUTED FOR OBA ARO OF GOGO – Respondent

ISSUE(S) FROM THE CAUSE(S) OF ACTION

NA

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE ISSUE(S)

ACTION:- Adjournment — Circumstances for adjournment of hearing

DECISION(S) OF THE WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL

Held (allowing the Appeal):

Where, owing to a relevant appeal, the hearing of a case would work injustice to a party, it should be adjourned pending the determination of the appeal.

MAIN JUDGMENT

FOSTER-SUTTON, P.

In our opinion there is substance in the point raised by counsel for the appellants. In view of the fact that there was an appeal pending in a Suit involving ownership of land which is the subject of the present Suit the proper course for the learned trial Judge to have adopted would have been to adjourn the case pending determination of the appeal, with liberty to either side to apply for the hearing to be continued. To do otherwise would work an injustice to the appellants in the event of their appeal in Ekiti Divisional Native Court Suit No. 2 of 1949 being successful, as they could not then renew their claim in the present suit.

We accordingly allow this appeal, set aside the judgment of the Court below and remit this suit to the Court below for it to be adjourned sine die with liberty to either party to apply for the hearing to take place.

The costs of the first trial to abide the result of the new trial, any costs paid by the appellants to the respondents to be refunded.

The appellants to have their costs on this appeal fixed at £32 4s. 0d.

Appeal allowed.