33 Comments in moderation

West African Court of Appeal & Privy Council

REX

V.

JOSEPH OLAGBAIYE

WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL HOLDEN AT LAGOS, NIGERIA

20TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 1936

2PLR/1936/56 (WACA)

OTHER CITATION(S)

2PLR/1936/56 (WACA)

(1936) III WACA P. 167 – 168

LEX (1936) – III WACA PP. 167 – 168

BEFORE THEIR LORDSHIPS:

DONALD KINGDON, C.J., NIGERIA

PETRIDES, C.J., GOLD COAST

WEBBER, C.J., SIERRA LEONE

BETWEEN:

REX – Respondent

AND

JOSEPH OLAGBAIYE – Appellant

ORIGINATING COURT(S)

APPEAL FROM CONVICTION AND SENTENCE BY SUPREME COURT.

REPRESENTATION

Appellants in person

Ivor Brace — for Crown

ISSUE((S) FROM THE CAUSE(S) OF ACTION

CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE – ILLEGAL COINING AND COUNTERFEITING:- Preparation for coining contra section 148(3)(c) Criminal Code and unlawful possession of counterfeit coin contrary to section 152(3) Criminal Code — Conviction on both counts — Concurrent sentences of four years’ imprisonment with hard labour imposed by Trial Court

DECISION(S) OF THE WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL

Held: Sentences enhanced to seven years owing to prevalence of particular crime

MAIN JUDGMENT

The following judgment was delivered:- KINGDON, C.J. NIGERIA

There is no substance in the appeal against conviction and it is dismissed. As to the sentence this Court is of opinion that having regard to the prevalence of this particular crime the sentences passed are inadequate.

The sentences passed at the trial are accordingly quashed, and in substitution therefore the appellant is sentenced to seven years’ imprisonment with hard labour on each count to run concurrently and to date from the 7th July, 1936.